05May2024

Mwathane When Property Use Rights are Adversely Affected by Roads, yet cannot be Compensated

LAND REFORMS IN KENYA AND AROUND AFRICA

This blog focuses on issues of land reforms in Kenya and around Africa and related matters

  • Home
    Home This is where you can find all the blog posts throughout the site.
  • Categories
    Categories Displays a list of categories from this blog.
  • Tags
    Tags Displays a list of tags that has been used in the blog.
  • Bloggers
    Bloggers Search for your favorite blogger from this site.
  • Team Blogs
    Team Blogs Find your favorite team blogs here.
  • Login

When Property Use Rights are Adversely Affected by Roads, yet cannot be Compensated

Posted by on in Land Laws
  • Font size: Larger Smaller
  • Hits: 446
  • Subscribe to this entry
  • Print
  • PDF

Roads connect people and places for development

Roads are a delight. They connect villages, towns and cities for our social and economic activities. Often, roads upgrade lifestyles, and values to abutting properties. But while roads are ordinarily celebrated, they occasionally can also degrade our businesses or residences.

Road alignments follow the shortest possible corridors, with least resistance to construction and movement. And to minimize compensation and destruction of existing properties, where possible, roads traverse existing public reserves. The final road design and construction is therefore a function of multiple parameters tied to land values and project costs. This constraining matrix explains why roads bring joy to most, but agony to some.

Compensation for acquired properties; not noise and dust nuisance

Our law currently provides that where private land has to be compulsorily acquired for a public purpose, such as a road, then just and prompt compensation is paid. Legislation further prescribes that any compensation should take into account the market value of the acquired property, the damage occasioned and the costs of relocation where applicable. But there are cases that don’t align to this narrow band targeted by our law, yet suffer adverse effects from road construction. And until our jurisprudence is gradually refined, proprietors to such properties have hardly any wriggle room for legal recourse. They are sour losers.

In Nairobi, we for instance witnessed the upgrade and expansion of Thika Road to a superhighway. Many businesses fronted parts of the old highway between Pangani and Ruiru. They tapped direct access, and hence business, from it. Oblivious to the fact that the highway would once get expanded, some erected permanent developments right next to the road, though within their boundaries. So when expansion happened, much as such properties were left intact and hence outside the compensation list, accesses to their business where cut off, or left exposed to high speed traffic, unsuitable to business. This happened to some businesses along Murang’a Road too. The recent expansion of Outer-Ring Road dealt a similar blow to some of the businesses. Though their property boundaries were left intact, their business frontages were so adversely affected that they’d to either close, be content with reduced earnings or change business models completely.

Mind future road expansion when positioning developments

The elevated JKIA-Westlands expressway under construction will similarly affect some premium properties. Occupants to some high-rise developments along the corridor will have to tolerate the sudden nuisance from high-speed traffic right next to their third or fourth floor offices or residences. In the rural areas, many are wont to erecting their residences right next to access roads. Usually, they keep their eyes on the existing road carriage and not the road reserve, hence contending with a false sense of privacy. When road expansion happens, such residences suffer endless dust and noise pollution. Where they are rental, value declines.

So it behooves us to keep an eye on the future when making choices for construction or renting of offices or residences, particularly where these are near existing or proposed roads.

 

Dated 2nd April, 2021

0
  • No comments made yet. Be the first to submit a comment

Leave your comment

Guest Sunday, 05 May 2024

Blog Calendar

Loading ...